It’s not too often that you get to hear the same band with the same personnel play the same song on the same recording date and give it two entirely different feels.
The band I’m referring to is basically a one time deal called “The Chocolate Dandies.” This particular aggregation recorded for Commodore Records in New York City over 60 years ago on May 25, 1940. They made six recordings that day including two versions of “I Can’t Believe That You’re In Love With Me.”
The first version was brought to my attention twice by two separate people. Skye Humphries first mentioned it to me last summer, and then I later heard Naomi Uyama play it while DJ’ing at The Jam Cellar one evening.
This is actually called “I Can’t Believe That You’re In Love With Me #2,” but I heard this one first. Shoot me.
It’s pretty slow at about 127 beats per minute, just barely skimming the line between being able to swingout to it and straight up ballad. The thing that helps blur that line is the playing of the front men who will all speed up as often as they slow it down during their solo’s without changing the overall tempo. This is a master class on how to swing. The effect at this tempo gives the song a nice dynamic that keeps listeners and dancers on their toes without confusing them. I think it’s just a gorgeous song to dance to. Not pretty or cute. I’m talking about the definition of beauty for the ears.